Oil Price, Recession: Causes, Issues and Risks

As one of many whose bread and butter is in the oil and gas industry, the price of oil further plunging to around $41.35 dollars a barrel conjures a worrisome landscape. Today’s decline (August 14, 2015) is almost a full $3 decrease from Friday’s figure, a six-year low (Figure 1). Yesterday’s price was another low at $42.12 a barrel which is another 6Y low in less than two weeks with today’s low of almost a full dollar increment in just a day. Where are we heading now? What is the future of Alberta’s Oil Sand?

Figure 1-WTI Oil Price (2011 to 2015)

This continuing overall trend has now increased the probability that the grim economic projection made in 2014 by several economic soothsayers has really started and gaining momentum. These financial experts predicted that the worst financial crisis known to modern man is bound to occur in the later part of 2015 and through 2016, well into 2017. Similar projection came from known economic analysts who claimed to have accurately predicted the 2006 American real estate collapse and the 2008/2009 worldwide economic downturn.

The certainty of oil breaking below the $40 mark is now very high (we are almost touching it), below $35 is high, and below $30 is medium, taking the price momentum as indicator; driven by a more divided world.

There is a period of disengagement between major oil producers as they jockey their own horses to alleviate their individual government deficit. Oil produced from foreign oil powers have continuously find their way to North America because of their relatively lower cost, that is, despite transportation risks that accompany them. The future landscape is looking more formidable and scarier.

The world’s oil cartel refuses to cut back on production in an effort to maintain market share rather than strengthen prices (Berthelsen, C., 2015).

All related events that we see now, follow similar patterns of events in the past that can be valuable risk indicators. The issue of oil price steep dive is one of them ushering financial and social risk on the horizon. We do not need the Bank of Canada to declare that we are now in a recession. We know we are! Acceptance is the beginning of awareness but does it make us feel better?

The issues of today can easily generate the risks of tomorrow (Frago, R. (2015).Risk-based Management in the World of Threats and Opportunities). Complex as it seems, it is simply the law of supply and demand in an unpredictable, volatile global geo-political environment.

Here are the some of the root causes of the oil price plunge.

  • Uncontrolled oil production of major oil producer (even OPEC was reported not seeing eye to eye) resulting in over-supply (glut)
  • Several major refinery shutdowns (increases pump prices and puts crude oil on queue further feeding the glut)
  • Not enough refineries to process oil (throughput capacity not enough)
  • Iran’s potentially returning in full to the market (considered to be 2nd or 3rd biggest oil producer after Saudi Arabia before the last sanction took effect). Knowing the possibility that the lifting of sanction will take effect soon under the complacent watch of the present US Administration, Saudi Arabia and other Gulf States are pumping their oil in advance to capture all of Iran’s possible and would be market shares. Who can really say whether it is not what’s really happening now?
  • Too many O&G growth projects worldwide (many have shelved theirs but this will not address today’s concern)
  • Large hoarded oil inventories got caught in the glut and nowhere to go
  • Reported ISIS control of several oil fields (selling at very low price in the black market)
  • Adding fuel to the commodity price meltdown was the unexpected decision by the Chinese Central Bank to devalue the yuan by two per cent overnight Monday, August 10, 2015 (Yedlin, D., 2015.Calgary Herald).
  • Lack of oil transport infrastructure (Key stone pipeline still in limbo with materials now rotting away)
  • Lack of constructive political engagement everywhere even in Alberta (Obama, a democrat and Harper, a conservative, could not strike a deal. Now that the USA, supposedly the closest Canadian trading partner and allies seems to be heading to a Republican sweep next year, Canadians might end up voting for the NDP. This is not to mention that Alberta is now under the NDP watch after the governing Tory made the greatest political blunder in the history of the province. What a mess!)

Hedging protection of some oil players will soon expire and companies that do not have a complete oil & gas portfolio will soon buckle for eventual take-over. As producing companies and even attractive unfinished projects becomes available for low cost acquisition, large companies will opt to shelve theirs in favor of the more inexpensive take-over.

This scenario will become more and more a reality in Canada where oil production is relatively more expensive compared to conventional method used by competitors. As the oil price heads to cut into the breakeven point, then there will be some drastic decisions in the making.

To many still employed and enjoying the many of life’s comfort, the Sword of Damocles is upon us. Many of our peers have gone without work for months. So how does one prepare for more threats to come? How do we mitigate the impact of the financial risk that this oil price brings? Do you have any suggestion?

On a positive note, investors and companies should remind themselves that the issues of today will pass in due time. It is the principle of change. Nothing in this world remains the same. We only sometimes think they are, but they are not. All investments look at the future prospects. While things are down today, the profits are for the taking years down the road. In the midst of the threats before us are opportunities. As the saying goes, “every cloud has a silver lining.”

Wisdom to remember: “A good and balanced decision maker is not driven mainly by the happenings of today, but more on the prospects of tomorrow (Frago, R., 2015.Draft Manuscript-The Future of Canadian Business).”

Rufran (081415)-Author (The above article was first published in LinkedIn Pulse, 081415)

Other articles authored by Rufran Frago:

  1. Risks Surrounding Canada’s TFW Part 1
  2. Risks as a Function of Time
  3. Project Schedule: P50, Anyone?
  4. Changing the Culture of Your Organization
  5. A Person Perceives Others Based on His Own Interest
  6. How Can Management Motivate and Empower?
  7. How Can Managers Increase Leadership Effectiveness
  8. Risks Surrounding Canada’s TFW Part 2
  9. Scaffolding Hours: What are they? Directs or Indirects? Part 2

ANNOUNCEMENT! The paperback and Kindle edition of the book “Risk-based Management in the World of Threats and Opportunities: A Project Controls Perspective” are now available. Please follow the hyperlinks for more information.

The book provides new/additional knowledge to project management practitioners (beginners to experts), risk management specialists, project controls people, estimators, cost managers, planners and schedulers, and for students of undergraduate courses in Risk Management. The sectional contents offer practical and common sense approach to identifying/managing risks. It is a must have for company managers, directors, supervisors, aspiring industry professionals, and even those students fresh from high school. The material is especially design to start with the foundational principles of risk gradually bringing the reader to deeper topics using a conversational style with simple terminologies.

So, if you are interested, check it out!


Source: Frago, R., 2015.Risk-based Management in the World of Threats and Opportunities: A Project Controls Perspective


About rcfrago

Rufran C. Frago, P. Eng., PMP, CCP, PMI-RMP, is the Founder/CEO of PM solution Pro, a tradename/trademark of Risk-based Management and Services Inc., a Canadian company focusing on project/business risk-based management consulting, business development, creative products, and training services. Senior project consultant, planner, scheduler, engineer, business developer, published author, with deep, diversified experience in management and controls. Hands-on work experience in engineering, maintenance, reliability program, operation, EH&S, training, and administration. Recognized subject matter expert by peers in project and Turn-around maintenance planning and scheduling, schedule quality assessment, and risk analysis. Proficient in project management framework, processes, tools, systems, and applications. Risk-based practitioner who value safety, integrity, ethics, and professionalism. Mr. Frago's personal work philosophy: "My client's success is also my own!" He has many years of international industry-related work ‎experience in Oil & Gas, Petrochemicals, Oleo-chemicals, Sugar Refining, Power/Utilities/Nuclear, Manufacturing, Consulting, and Education. He has worked in various parts of the world (Location: Asia, Middle East, Canada, and North Africa). Rufran has worked with Caltex, Uniman, Unichem (now Cocochem), ARAMCO-KSA, Central Azucarera de Tarlac, Arabian Gulf Oil Company-Libya, Batangas State University, Saint Bridget's College, JG Summit Petrochemicals, Halliburton-Kellogg, Brown and Root, OPTI Canada, and Suncor Energy Inc. His expertise includes risk-based project management, risk analysis, planning & scheduling, cost management, auditing, maintenance, operation, EH&S and reliability engineering. He is interested in providing solutions and innovations to all clients and stakeholders. Mr. Frago is a risk management professional. He studied at BSU graduating with a Diploma in Petroleum Refinery Maintenance Technician, and BS Mechanical Engineering. He also has a Bachelors degree in Management Engineering from UB. He took up MBA courses under UP-PBMIT Consortium. Rufran completed Computer Technician Program at ICS-Pennsylvania, USA, APM Certificate program at SAIT-Calgary, and PM Certificate program-Construction Management. He is presently taking up PM Certificate program-Risk Management at University of Calgary. He was a recipient of the Gerry Roxas Leadership Award, the American Field Service (AFS) Scholarship grant, and the CALTEX scholarship grant where he specialized in Petroleum Refinery Maintenance. The author wants to share his knowledge and leave behind some legacy to all readers, most especially to his wife, children and lovely grandchildren, Eva and Mia.
This entry was posted in Business, Causes and effects, Economics, Issues and Problems, Oil Future, Oil Marketing, Project Management, Risk Assessment and Treatment, Risk-based Management and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s